Trending
America’s two political parties, the oldest and third-oldest in the world, face new challenges as a result of the Democrats’ “more than a thumping” of President Donald Trump’s Republicans.
The Democrats, of course, have the happier task of deciding what to do with their unexpectedly wide majorities in the Senate and House of Representatives.
Their capture of at least eight Senate seats - nine if their current leads hold up in Alaska - in states that Trump carried by double-digit margins just two years ago gives them a majority that looks likely to last at least four and quite possibly six years. That’s because most of the party’s seats that are up in 2028 are in states that have been safely Democratic for years.
The party’s majority in the House looks formidable but not impervious, overturnable as it is by seat gains of the size achieved three times in recent years, by Republicans in 2010 and Democrats in 2018 and again this year.
But the great opportunity, and the great risk, for Democrats is the fact that they seem to be the one party with a plausible chance to win a trifecta - the White House and both houses of Congress - in 2028. That’s a big contrast from recent history, in which one party or the other has won trifectas in seven of the last nine elections.
Their win this year pretty clearly owes little to their policies or political leadership. An exit poll showed an electorate with a 49% to 43% party identification edge for Democrats but with 52% expressing unfavorable feelings toward the Democratic Party.
Most voters were clearly eager for the opposition party to curb the power and capriciousness of the incumbent president. It doesn’t necessarily follow that the larger electorate in the presidential year will be ready to give Democrats control of both the executive and legislative branches.
That’s especially true if Democrats follow through on their threats to abolish the Senate filibuster. The impulse for checks and balances that worked for Democrats this year could work against them two years from now.
Precedent for that exists in the era of polarized partisan parity that has prevailed since the early 1990s. Many Democratic politicians retain a sentimental attachment to the idea that they represent a downtrodden working class, even as affluent college graduates have become one of their bedrock constituencies.
After they won trifectas in 1992, 2008 and 2020, they pushed policies of economic redistribution - health insurance changes in 1993-94 and 2009-10, and countercyclical spending in 2021. Each time, they have been rebuked by the voters, massively in the 1994 and 2010 off-years, and more narrowly but decisively in 2022 and 2024.
Democrats with long memories, like Rahm Emanuel, may recommend only modest economic changes. But others with shorter perspectives may give in to redistributionist impulses that prove unnerving in a country where most people, for all their complaints, live comfortably.
Another danger for Democrats, decisive in 2024 but (perhaps temporarily) irrelevant in 2026, was what Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-N.Y.) laughingly dubbed last August as “Woke 1.” This showed considerable adroitness from Ocasio-Cortez, whose 2018 defeat of a House Democratic leader put her in the spotlight with colleagues calling for defunding the police and for sex change surgery for transgender prisoners.
My guess is that Democratic congressional leaders and presidential candidates will similarly be inclined to leave “Woke 1” behind but may not be able to muffle the highly visible socialists who want to abolish capitalism and close down prisons. And Democrats may not be able to resist the temptation to overreach in their investigations of, and impeachment attempts against, Trump appointees and Trump himself. On this week’s roll call, every House Democrat voted to proceed on the impeachment of War Secretary Pete Hegseth.
Republicans face the task of adjusting to the voters’ rejection of the president who has battered their party to subservience. Astonishingly, the first to take up cudgels was Vice President JD Vance, who in an X post the afternoon after Election Day blamed the result entirely on the Iran “war.”
In contrast, Secretary of State Marco Rubio has been careful not to oppose the president openly, even while delivering in Munich and Athens eloquent speeches describing the common historic origins and philosophic links of European and American traditions. It has been assumed, and Rubio has stated, that he would not run for president again, as he did in 2016, if Vance were a candidate.
Nevertheless, a poll conducted by highly rated AtlasIntel the weekend before the election showed Rubio leading Vance by a 46% to 33% margin. Atlas showed splintered results on the Democratic side - 18% each for Ocasio-Cortez and Sen. Jon Ossoff (D-Ga.), who just won his second Senate term by a 59% to 41% margin, and 16% for former Transportation Secretary Pete Buttigieg.