Committee rejects ordinance repeal, moves forward with revisions
Trending
An ad hoc committee's 40-minute discussion on whether a human relations committee should be part of city government ended with a decision to begin to draft an outline for one.
Holding its second meeting, the City of Minot's ad hoc human relations committee on Tuesday voted 3-5 to reject a motion recommending the city council abandon a human relations committee ordinance.
Last week, the city council clarified the committee's status as ad hoc and put a Dec. 31 moratorium on its work after some committee members questioned whether the committee was set up legally.
Committee member Mike Blessum, who had raised the legality issue at the first meeting, said the council's resolution had to be done to "get things on the right track." He added the resolution said the committee should look at whether a human relations committee ordinance should exist and, if so, what adjustments to the ordinance articles should be made.
"I'd like us to have a discussion around whether there should be an article in the first place," Blessum said. He moved the committee recommend the council repeal the existing human relations committee ordinance and discontinue the ad hoc committee.
"While there are many reasons for the city and its residents to promote Minot and to make it a place that is safe and welcoming for all, we do not believe that a human relations committee is the best path forward for the city," his motion stated.
"Issues with housing, transportation, public safety should be taken up by city staff under the direction of the city manager instead of trying to use a volunteer group of unelected committee members to handle these topics," Blessum said. "The people of Minot have safe and welcoming built into who they are. In my opinion, this is not the role for government. This is not the role for an unelected board as a branch of government to be doing in the city. I think the people of the city do it on their own, and I think that we should support them in doing that."
Committee member Miranda Schuler said the committee needs to stick with its plans for ordinance review as previously laid out.
"If we were to pass this," she said of Blessum's motion, "it will give an air of a lack of transparency for the citizens by sending it straight back to city council."
Committee member Denise Dykeman said promoting the general welfare is the role of government, as stated in the preamble to the U.S. Constitution.
"It's very important for us to have a committee on this, which can consider the views of different people in the city, what their experiences are and how we can make them feel more involved in the city," she said. "We do have an obligation to care about our citizens and civil rights in Minot."
Committee member Christine Staley agreed.
"It's only right and only fair, and I think they need to have a voice. This is the only way to have it," she said.
Blessum said he needs to better understand the concerns around human relations.
"It sounds like, in your opinion, we have major issues that we need to deal with in the Minot area," Blessum said. "I don't see that. I may not see the things that are out there, but I need to see them, and that's the discussion we need to have before we start ticking off the boxes, writing a new ordinance. I don't even know what we're trying to do."
Committee member Lianne Zeltinger also wanted to hear from people who don't feel safe and welcome.
"But more importantly, what actions have happened that make them unsafe. Actions are something that government can deal with," she said. "I would love to hear where that discrimination is, what the actions are, because that should be taken care of."
Dykeman cited a U.S. Commission on Human Rights report that found discrimination in employment, housing and other areas are commonplace in North Dakota.
Committee co-chairman and city council member Scott Burlingame voiced reluctance about having the public come and share stories.
"One of the things I do know from my professional experience is the more people have to tell their stories, especially if it's trauma-related stories, the more they can sort of be re-victimized. So the last thing I ever want to do is to create an opportunity for people to come forward and tell us something if we're not the right place for people telling these stories," he said.
The committee voted 3-5 to defeat Blessum's motion for repeal. Blessum was joined by Travis Zablotney and Zeltinger in supporting the motion.
The committee went on to approve "human relations committee" as the title of the group created by the ordinance. It approved goals and objectives that include:
- to provide leadership in the areas of civil and human rights.
- to promote respect for all people.
- to identify issues of concern regarding civil rights in Minot and to make recommendations to the city council.
- to encourage adherence to federal and state laws regarding civil and human rights.
City council member Carrie Evans had previously offered that general outline, and council member Mark Jantzer also supported it, in their proposed drafts to replace existing objectives in the ordinance. The current ordinance lists objectives as:
- act as a sounding board for the identification and resolution of community human relations problems.
- identify and eliminate minor irritants before they develop into major problems.
- evaluate discriminatory conditions and practices and make recommendations to the civilian or military authority concerning these problem areas.
The committee meets again Sept. 12 at 5:30 p.m. The officer roles on a human relations committee will be among items on the agenda.