Breaking News
Local News

Verdict in three hours: Guilty

Two Minot residents found guilty for Goodale murder

By Charles Crane 4 min read
Regina Goodale, her attorney Steven Mottinger, Attorney Steven Hartl and Mathew Anderson listen as the 12 jurors are polled after delivering their guilty verdicts in Goodale and Anderson’s murder trial in Minot on Friday.

The man and woman on trial for the murder of Wayne Goodale have been found guilty after around three hours of deliberations by the jury.

The 12-person jury reached its verdict after three days of testimony from 32 witnesses during the trial, finding Mathew Anderson, 35, guilty of Class A felony murder, and his co-defendant Regina Goodale, 35, guilty as his accomplice in the murder of her estranged husband. Wade Goodale, 42, died on Feb. 24, 2022, after being attacked and shot by Anderson, who was in a relationship with Regina Goodale at the time.

Ward County State's Attorney Roza Larson, in presenting her closing statement Friday morning, implored the jury to "keep your eye on the ball."

"This was a willful act that caused the death of Wade Goodale under extreme indifference to the value of his life. Mister Anderson is the one who pulled the trigger," Larson said. "He's guilty of murder and she's guilty as an accomplice to murder."

Larson referenced evidence that showed a firearm purchased by Anderson was the weapon that fired the shot that killed Wade Goodale and that Regina Goodale had shared facts with others that only could have been known by someone who was there. Larson asserted the defendants left the scene without rendering or requesting any medical assistance for Goodale before returning home, where they engaged in sexual activities.

"Then they went home and had sex, while he had bloody jeans on. That's cold indifference to human life," Larson said.

Anderson's defense Attorney William Hartl pushed back during his closing, arguing that evidence didn't show that his client wanted Goodale to die, pointing to jailhouse communications between Anderson and his wife in which he called the tragic events "an accident."

"They wanted him roughed up but there wasn't talk of ending his life," Hartl said. "This wasn't a willful act. Did the gun go off by accident? Guns can go off by accident. No one saw Mr. Anderson pull the trigger."

Hartl also called into question testimony from Whitney Racine, whom he said gave contradictory statements to investigators and in her testimony before the court regarding her whereabouts that evening. Racine had previously pleaded guilty to facilitating murder for her role in luring Wade Goodale to an address, knowing he was to be assaulted.

"If it weren't for Whitney Racine, we wouldn't be here. She set the whole thing up. She arranges for Wade to get beat up," Hartl said. "You can give Racine's testimony as much or as little credibility as you think it deserves. But you know her track record. Her track record is not good."

Regina Goodale's attorney Steven Mottinger echoed Hartl, saying that despite his client voicing frustrations over her marriage to others in the past, she never asked or sought anyone to kill her husband.

"Did they present any Snapchat or text communication between Whitney Racine and Regina Goodale? No, they didn't. [Racine] set this whole thing up. She's the one who is responsible, not Regina Goodale," Mottinger said. "None of them ever heard her express her desire for Wade Goodale to be killed. There's no credible evidence to suggest that she was involved in any conversation that set up what happened the night of the 23rd."

Wade Goodale's family let out small cries of satisfaction when the verdict was read.

Cresap ordered a pre-sentence investigation. Cresap said he expected the sentencing hearing will be scheduled in mid-October to provide ample time for the investigation. Anderson and Goodale's rights to appeal the verdicts will be presented at sentencing.

Starting at /week.