Mobile Version: mobile.minotdailynews.com
RSS:
Minot Weather Forecast, ND
Member Login: Email: Password:
Search: Local News Classified Web
News  Obituaries  Editorials  Local Sports  Sports  Features  TV Listings  Eatery Directory  Jobs  Local Classifieds  CU Galleries

Harvey church votes to leave ELCA

By JILL SCHRAMM, Staff Writer jschramm@minotdailynews.com
POSTED: January 3, 2010

Article Photos


Advertisement

The process of leaving the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America began for First Lutheran Church of Harvey on Dec. 6. The congregation, by a two-thirds vote, took the initial step toward cutting ties.

"It's a sad thing that we are put in this position where we have to do this. My heart grieves over that," the Rev. Fred Westerhold of First Lutheran said.

The congregation made the decision after the churchwide assembly voted to allow churches to call clergy who are in committed, same-sex relationships.

The Harvey church now is in the mandatory 90-day discernment period, during which it will continue to discuss its future plans. A second and final vote, which also requires a two-thirds majority, will be taken after that time.

Westerhold said the congregation hasn't determined which of about 18 different Lutheran church bodies that it would join if it does leave the ELCA. Other ELCA congregations in the area also are in discussion about their future plans, and Westerhold said if others decide to break away, they may look at moving together toward some other option.

Interest in joining the new Lutheran CORE also might depend on whether other area congregations go that route. Westerhold said an isolated congregation would have to make a concerted effort to find fellowship with other churches, particularly since the natural fellowship that would exist with the ELCA as a Lutheran body would be strained.

Members who want to stay in the ELCA rather than go with a break-away church face concerns of their own. For members of the Harvey congregation, the nearest ELCA churches, at least for now, would be in Fessenden or Bowdon. Depending on how many churches leave ELCA, the travel distance for those who want to remain in the ELCA could be long.

"There are no winners here," Westerhold said. "There are only losers no matter which way it goes."

Member Comments
View Comments: | 1-25 |26-27 | Post a comment
prochoicemom
01-21-10 1:21 PM
GUESS WHO HAD THE LAST WORD!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1

prochoicemom
01-12-10 7:52 AM
YOOHOO lars thunder, I am anxiously awaiting your most literate, highly informed and enlightened response. (although I can about guess what the contents would be with a high degree of accuracy, now, can't I!)

prochoicemom
01-12-10 7:51 AM
YOOHOO lars thunder, I am anxiously awaiting your most literate, highly informed and enlightened response. (although I can about guess what the contents would be with a high degree of accuracy, now, can't I!)

prochoicemom
01-08-10 7:12 PM
dear lars thunderation, Surely the Lord will smite me down if I don't fit your standards of a "good Lutheran" It is good that you question if I am a good Lutheran. it reveals two things 1. that you believe you are qualified to judge who is not and who is a good Lutheran, and that you would make an excellent member of the LCIC,or what the*****it calls itself, since they are about judgmentalism, not Christianity. 2. It reveals that you have a big hot air ego in your superiority over the rest of us. Pretty impressive.

LarsThunder
01-07-10 4:17 PM
prochoicemom, are you a Lutheran? If so, do you consider yourself a good Lutheran? If you answered yes to either question, I've got news for you - think again.

The Book of Concord was written, in part, by a guy named Martin Luther - heard of him? You know, the guy who was influential in getting this whole protestant movement started, the guy who nailed 95 thesis to a church door in Germany - kind of important to us Lutherans and to the protestant movement overall.

prochoicemom
01-07-10 2:08 PM
lars whatever do you mean a book about Concord, NH, about Concord grapes, a concordance for use with reading the Bible? Do YOU know what you are talking about? Enter the words "book of concord" in your search line and see how many thousand responses you get, duh.

LarsThunder
01-05-10 9:12 PM
How many of you actually have read your book of concord? Prochoicemom, do you know what the book of concord is without looking it up?

To repent means you are sorry for your sin. If you are a gay person, you are not sorry for your "sin" and you do not see it as a sin. That's what it means to repent.

Go back to 7th grade confirmation.

Here is the miraculous thing - we had these same arguments 35 years ago when the former church bodies that make up the ELCA started ordaining women. Bible verses tossed around how a woman should not have authority over a man.

Seems that worked itself out, didn't it?

prochoicemom
01-05-10 4:14 PM
I question Lars Thunder's qualifications to take part in intelligent discussion since he seems to fit the name of "Thunder" quite well. I would be glad to use the book (supposedly a book) "revealing the ELCA" for tp since it most likely is a fundamentalist diatribe that supports division, rather than inclusiveness. Probably read by the Flat Earth gang of baggers and birthers, fundamentalist perverts and psychotic palaverers. My how inmpressive. Christ is willing to include all of us and he forgives us hundreds of times because he knows we are imperfect and he is a loving God. The world is made up of doers, like the ELCA, who seek to include all persons in God's church, and the world also has critics who do nothing but ***** and moan and create divisions. Lars what the*****yer name is go count angelson a pinhead, that is what you must like to spend your time doing.

maxxie
01-05-10 3:55 PM
Do you forget what happened at Sodom & Gommorah? He did not let their sins continute--read the Bible.

OhHenry
01-05-10 7:38 AM
Prochoicemom. . .Where' the love?

LarsThunder. . .Are there no gays or divorced persons in heaven? If so, they didn't get there by not sinning anymore. . .They trusted in Christ's Mercy. Obeying the command "not to sin" is not repentance. Lutherans believe that repentance has two parts: Confession of sin and faith in one's absolution. Your all or none approach to the Law for Christians, for fear of hypocracy, leaves God's Mercy out of the equation. Unwittingly, that's what the ELCA does by "artifically" removing the Law against homosexuality. . .It throws repentant homosexuals (and God's Mercy) under the bus in favor of His Justice!

Luther2010
01-04-10 10:54 PM
Dan Skogen's web address: ExposingtheELCA Dot Com

Luther2010
01-04-10 10:52 PM
by Dan Skogen It's Time to Leave the ELCA

As the title says, I believe it is time to leave the denomination that long ago left God. God's Word is true and the ELCA has decided that their thoughts are above God's thoughts. This is evident in many ways that I don't think the typical ELCA member is aware of. Below I outline a number ways the ELCA has turned away from God and deny the very Word of God. The ELCA church, that I am a member of, is in the process of deciding what they will do regarding the ELCA and if they will leave the denomination. If you believe the Bible is God's Word and Jesus is the way to be saved, please stand up and let your voice be heard in your church. And tell others about it. Below is an email I sent the council members of my church. ***********exposingtheelca****/

LarsThunder
01-04-10 10:12 PM
Tell me how you can be a repentant gay person or a divorced person if you are still gay or divorced? Isn't that the sin you are guilty of committing? Repenting means you won't do it any more (or at least try not to), but if you are gay, then there is no way you can repent and continue sinning.

See, that's the hang-up, we as a God-fearing society pick and choose which rules we follow. If we are going to hide behind the bible for some, we best get it right all the time. Otherwise we are hypocrites.

prochoicemom
01-04-10 10:12 PM
By the way the lutheran church in Fontanelle, Iowa, voted to drop out of the ELCA and now one "member" stands by the door before the service as people walk in and says, "No *****s allowed". That is what they are setting themselves up for. It reeks of phariseism, hypocrisy, sanctimonious superiority. Just wait it will happen, and you homophobics will say, "It's not my fault". "Well, you voted it right in. Now you can be proud of your destruction. Oh, and get any paintings, art, music by gay artists out. Let's kill them too eventhough they have been dead for hundreds of years. Are they going to go back and expunge every art work, music, etc that might have been written by a gay person in the past??????????????????

prochoicemom
01-04-10 10:02 PM
OlHanry or whateveryourname is, where is no scriptural proof that Christ would do any of the things you so piously list, such as "He would not have abused God's grace by voting along with the churchwide assembly"? What Biblical based proof do you have of such conjectural actions you claim Christ would make? There is no proof for any of your statements, not a*****one. You did not respond concerning the Biblically based actions that I quoted. You sound like a non-substantive, high velocity wind tunnel, blowing loudly blabitta flapitta, meaning that you blab and flap your mouth and say nothing but your personal opinion, which you believe is the same as the word of God.

obtusegoose
01-04-10 7:36 PM
I think IntelShep said it best. The Bible supports slavery and condemns divorce. Yet, conveniently, those things are overlooked in 2010. But for some reason being gay isn't. This 'homosexual abomination' nonsense needs to end. It isn't 210 AD. Society isn't ignorant anymore. Stop using the Bible to justify bigotry.

UffdaGreg
01-04-10 5:16 PM
The founders of the ELCA sought council from Jesus' high priestly prayer. John 17, particularly verses 20-23. Jesus says, " 20 I pray not only for them, but also for those who believe in me because of their message. 21 I pray that they may all be one. Father, may they be in us just as you are in me and I am in you. May they be one so that the world may believe that you sent me. 22 I gave them the same glory you gave me so that they may be one, just as you and I are one. 23 I in them and you in me, so that they may be completely one, in order that the world may know that you sent me and that you love them as you love me."

Leaving and dividing the ELCA would be contrary to what Jesus would want, imho.

UffdaGreg
01-04-10 5:02 PM
...cont.

e) I have been asking the contrary minded if they have ever worked with a gay or lesbian and the parents of either. Almost to a person they answer with a no. I suggest that they might have a genuine learning experience if they did so.

f) And I must also take into consideration that Minot and other local churches do not know what it is like to do ministry in San Francisco, Los Angeles, New York City, Minneapolis or other cities where there is a concentration of gays and lesbians. If the decision of Church-wide meets a need in those communities - who are we to say otherwise. Upper Midwest congregations make for a very different scene. Some of St.Paul's counsel on bearing one another's burden seems come into play.

I believe Harvey made a very poor decision. A decision based in fear and complete and utter ignorance of the Bible and its intended meaning - especially the meaning of Jesus' teachings.

UffdaGreg
01-04-10 4:52 PM
My arguments for not withdrawing are:

a) In the Parable of the Wheat and Tares Jesus makes it clear that judgment is not for us to render - leave it to God and He will carry out His judgment in His time. In the meantime, just let it be.

b) In reading the New Testament the persons who said they could not be a part because it violated their sense of holiness were the Scribes and Pharisees - not the followers of Jesus.

c) When Martin Luther found the Church to be in error he did not propose withdrawing,. rather he took the approach of "Lets work on it". The Lutheran Church was born only after he was kicked out.

d) The Resolution allows every congregation to set its own policy - and some Bishops are encouraging a By-Law in the congregation's Constitution.

IntelShep
01-04-10 3:51 PM
I hope you guys realize that in 25 or 50 years people will view you guys in the same light as slave owners or the racist segregationist bigots of the mid 1900s.

If you can live with that, that's fine. But just know that it'll be your legacy.

And if you still want to hide your hatred behind the Bible then you should know it also has its say on other civil rights issues. Such as slavery:

" However, you may purchase male or female slaves from among the foreigners who live among you. You may also purchase the children of such resident foreigners, including those who have been born in your land. You may treat them as your property, passing them on to your children as a permanent inheritance. You may treat your slaves like this, but the people of Israel, your relatives, must never be treated this way. (Leviticus 25:44-46)"

"Slaves, obey your earthly masters with deep respect and fear. Serve them sincerely as you would serve Christ. (Ephesians 6:5)"

Walrus
01-04-10 3:14 PM
Reverend Ole is the pastor of the local Norwegian Lutheran Church, and Pastor Sven is the minister of the Swedish Covenant Church across the road.

One day they were seen pounding a sign into the ground, that said:

DA END ISS NEAR! TURN YERSELF AROUNT NOW BAFOR IT'S TOO LATE!

As a car sped past them, the driver leaned out his window and yelled,"Leave me alone, you Skandinhoovian religious nuts!"

From the curve they heard screeching tires and a big splash. Rev. Ole turns to Pastor Sven and asks,"Do ya tink maybe da sign should yust say,

Bridge Out?"

OhHenry
01-04-10 12:06 PM
Larsthunder posts this false dichotomy: One cannot be Lutheran and associate with gays, lesbians or divorced people. He forgets that God knows there are two types of gays, two types of lesbians, two types of divorced people, and two types of sinners: repentant and unrepentant. 1st Lutheran, Harvey understands this too!

LarsThunder
01-04-10 10:24 AM
If you subscribe to Martin Luther's viewpoints, then you best dissolve any relationship you have with people who are gay/lesbian. For simply knowingly associating with a sinner makes you a sinner as well. For that matter, you best stop associating with anyone who is divorced and remarried, because that is a sin as well.

What, divorce a sin? It goes against God's teaching, especially if the woman gets remarried.

We can't pick and choose God's teaching's we embrace. If you are going to insist on following one, then you best embrace them all.

Or, we could take Jesus advice and love our neighbor as we love ourselves. That's a radical thought if I ever heard one.

Luther2010
01-04-10 9:43 AM
Martin Luther -- "Christmas Day Sermon" ". . . The preachers are to be angels, that is, God's messengers, who are to lead a heavenly life, are to be constantly engaged with God's Word that they under no circumstances preach the doctrine of men. It is a most incongruous thing to be God's messenger and not to further God's message. . . .The message also is of more importance than the messenger's life. If he leads a wicked life he only injures himself, but if he brings a false message in the place of God's message, he leads astray and injures every one that hears him, and causes idolatry among the people in that they accept lies for the truth, honor men instead of God . . . . "There is no more terrible plague or cause for distress upon earth than a preacher who does not preach God's Word; of whom, alas, the world today is full. . .now they go along under spiritual names and show, as priest, bishop . . . and are at the same time ravening wolves in sheeps' clothin

OhHenry
01-04-10 9:24 AM
Prochoicemom asks, "How would Christ have voted?" He would not have abused God's grace by voting along with the ELCA's Churchwide Assembly. He would not have promoted an enabling grace that ignores God's words of Law. He would not have led everyone to the Temple top, had them join hands, and asked everyone to jump in the misguided notion that this is how the church proves its "love". He would not have promised that His angels would guard over everyone lest they dash their feet against a stone, unrepentance notwithstanding. Insead, he would have said to those who promote such a promiscuous, antinomian grace: "Thou shalt not put the Lord your God to a Foolish Test". And the majority of members at First Lutheran Church, Harvey apparently agree!

You must first login before you can comment.
Existing Member Login
Not a Member?
Create a Member Account  
*Your email address:
*Password:
    Forgot Password?
  Remember my email address.
News  Obituaries  Editorials  Local Sports  Sports  Features  TV Listings  Eatery Directory  Jobs  Local Classifieds  CU Galleries